“Israel” From Concealment to Conduct Genocide, by Dr. Adel Samara

“Israel” From Concealment to Conduct Genocide

Palestinians: From the Loss of the Embrace to a Sense of Orphanhood

And th​e Solution Does Not Lie in the Knesset

Dr. Adel Samara

Occupied Palestine

Many Arab analysts, politicians, intellectuals, and academics may be reluctant to acknowledge that Benjamin Netanyahu has benefited from and capitalized on normalization, from Menachem Begin to Mohammed bin Zayed. This normalization has covered up his vulnerability resulting from October 7. Indeed, Arab normalization—or rather, official Arab submission, the suppression of Arab public opinion, and the opportunism of sixth-column intellectuals—has given him the opportunity to manufacture several wars.

 Regardless of the extent of their achievements, these wars have firmly established an issue that Arabs must acknowledge without stubborn denial. They must acknowledge it, if only to avoid deceiving themselves and others. That issue is:

Arab regimes and their instruments have give  ”Israel” the opportunity to plunge without limits into Palestinian blood and Palestinian soil. No one can plausibly claim that this was not the principal achievement upon which Netanyahu, Ben-Gvir, and Smotrich have built their political standing.

Concealment, so that it does not appear mysterious, is a historical component of the Zionist movement. In order to win the support of Soviet revisionism, the movement early on adorned itself with a socialist label through the establishment of kibbutzim. These kibbutzim, however, were nothing more than a component of the capitalist market of Jewish settlement in Palestine. As the decades passed and the socialist bloc disintegrated, the kibbutzim became like a military uniform worn by a retired general and passed down to his children. In other words, Zionism no longer needed to wear socialist earrings and ornaments.

Naturally, the trajectory of the “Israel’s supposed “socialism” coincided with the hostility of Arab regimes, and even ordinary Arab populations, toward socialism. This further increased the support that many communists around the world extended to “Israel”.

However, the most extensive and dangerous practice of concealment, followed by its gradual abandonment, occurred in conjunction with, and in precise chronological sequence with, the following developments:

  • The defeat of the Arab unity state at the hands of the territorial, nation-state regimes Qutriya.
  • The decline of Arab nationalist culture and struggle among the Arab public, accompanied by a retreat into the narrow horizons of individual territorial states Qutriya.
  • The visual field no longer needed to extend any further; in other words, a degree of political blindness had set in.
  • The infiltration of many Arab rulers into “Israel ‘s” intelligence networks, acting as spies and informing it about the preparations of Arab nationalist-oriented regimes. Some of these intelligence activities have been publicly exposed. They include King Abdullah I of Jordan’s relationship with Golda Meir; King Hassan II of Morocco’s provision of a room adjacent to the Arab Summit Conference in 1965 for Mossad agents; King Hussein of Jordan’s advance notification to “Israel” about the October 1973 War; and, eventually, Mohammed bin Zayed and Egyptian intelligence informing “Israel” that Hamas was planning to undertake some action in October 2023. These confirmed facts are sufficient to illustrate how the “Israel’s” gradual implementation of its doctrine, as the destruction of the Arab body intensified, coincided with its abandonment of concealment. This is because the declared Zionist objective has always been, at the very least, the occupation of all Palestine.
  • The normalization of relations in 1979 by Egypt’s ruling bourgeoisie, the suspension of Egypt’s membership in the Arab League, and its subsequent reinstatement—all of which meant that the various Arab regimes accepted normalization.
  • The Palestinians’ involvement in recognizing “Israel” and their descent into the catastrophe of Oslo-stan.
  • Then came the wave of normalization during Trump’s presidency, involving the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain, and Morocco, not to mention the actual but undeclared normalization that had already been taking place.

Consequently, the leadership of “Israel” moved from talking about peace, to negotiations, to the two-state solution, and then to the distortion of that solution through Oslo. It subsequently moved to openly declaring that it opposed not only the establishment of a Palestinian state but even the very existence of the Palestinian people, advocating instead their extermination.

Following the October 27, 2026 Knesset elections, Netanyahu declared war on the Palestinians of the territories occupied in 1948, in addition to the multifaceted war against the West Bank and the various forms of genocide and slow destruction inflicted upon Gaza.”Israel” no longer has any reason to conceal its intentions.

Perhaps what is particularly striking is that “Israel” has repeatedly abandoned and violated its various agreements with these Arab regimes, while those regimes continue to cling to agreements whose outcomes have consistently benefited “Isarel” alone.

Anyone who fails to understand that the official Arab regimes, which have concealed their conduct behind the cowardice of Islamic regimes, were never beyond the scrutiny of the world’s official governments is simply demonstrating ignorance. The positions of these international governments have been negatively aligned with the opportunism and submissiveness of Arab regimes, including during and after the genocidal war in Gaza. Western governments continued supplying “Israel” with weapons, if not entire air-attack capabilities. Meanwhile, Arab and Islamic regimes continued declaring their abandonment of Gaza, and subsequently the West Bank and Lebanon, at the Riyadh Conference of November 11, 2023. At the same conference on the same date in 2024, they effectively declared that they would not even provide Gaza with a carton of milk.

Consequently, any leader of “Israel” would be a traitor or a fool if he did not continue the destruction. Likewise, any regime in the world would be foolish or betraying its own interests if it genuinely stood with the Palestinians after Arab and Islamic regimes had abandoned them—and had even produced intellectuals who condemn the Al-Aqsa Flood!

Naturally, there are some intermediate positions motivated by humanitarian considerations alone, with Spain being an example.

What About Orphanhood?

Many attribute to Jabotinsky the original formulation of the idea that the Israel” must continue its aggression against the Arabs until they reach a condition of cowardice in which they are no longer even capable of contemplating resistance. They overlook the fact that Ben-Gurion declared that he was prepared to pay an Arab prince one million liras to wage war against “Israel”, because “Israel” cannot survive without war. He also maintained that “Israel’s” survival depended on fragmenting Syria, among other things.

What we mean is that there is absolutely no disagreement between one Zionist leader and another. The Arabs who attempted—or even became emotionally invested in—manufacturing distinctions between one Zionist leader and another were nothing more than people who had internalized defeat. Their motivation was to conceal their role in normalization or their readiness to normalize relations. Perhaps the circles promoting normalization have become saturated and no longer need them.

In the context of serving and participating in psychological warfare, the Arab media of defeat portrays “Israel’s” power as autonomous and absolute, despite the fact that Jabotinsky explicitly stated that “Israel” would depend on the West. Ben-Gurion and all the various leaders of “Israel”, up to Netanyahu and Eisenkot, relied on, continue to rely on, and will continue to rely on the West. This confirms that the real and original enemy is Britain and other Western powers, while the United States subsequently led the military camp on behalf of the occupation.

This became evident when Netanyahu succeeded in mobilizing Trump to launch attacks in accordance with the “Israel’s” wishes, as he has done and will continue to do against Iran! This reveals a truth that reinforces what we have already outlined: these Arab regimes, which have long shamefully boasted about their friendship and alliance with the United States, are, in reality, a source of strength for “Israel”, at least in terms of the ultimate consequences of their policies.

Regarding the role of the United States, Brzezinski wrote, following the “Isear’s” defeat in 2006, that America’s withdrawal from the Middle East would mean the end of “Israel.”

On the basis of all this, the United States and “Israel” are conducting psychological warfare designed to shatter the nerves of the Arab nation. They do so through the continuous repetition, by the machinery of official Arab media—with its enslaved broadcasters and analysts—of two damaging and poisonous messages:

  • Trump says that he might attack Iran within days, or perhaps after the elections, or perhaps at some other time, and so on. This is clearly an act of humiliation and contempt toward Islamic countries, as Trump repeatedly indulges in the pleasure of deciding whether or not to strike, whenever his whims dictate.
  • Netanyahu struts about, boasting that he has opened seven fronts, thereby insulting all Arabs, and declaring that he will continue opening new fronts until he realizes the “Israel’s” expansionist scheme from the Euphrates to the Nile.

Meanwhile, on the evening when the results of the Knesset elections were announced a few days ago, Netanyahu finally let the cat out of the bag, declaring that the Arabs in the territories occupied in 1948 are enemies, and that any Jewish reliance on them, or any alliance between a Jewish political bloc and them, constitutes treason.

Of course, Netanyahu does not care about Arabs or Muslims in general. They are, after all, kneeling and prostrating before “Israel”. More importantly, he does not care about the rest of the world either. He no longer talks about “Israel” as a secular, democratic state, a state governed by the rule of law, or a state of institutions. The entire world lies beneath his feet. This is not merely because he wants to protect himself from the judiciary; rather, the prevailing circumstances have created an environment that allows him to act in this manner.

But how did the Palestinians of 1948 come to experience orphanhood?

The Arab nation refused to recognize “Israel” both before and after 1948. Accordingly, Arab communist parties that recognized “Israel” were condemned, despite—or perhaps because of—their reliance on and pride in their adherence to the Soviet revisionist position, which never changed!

However, territorial Arab regimes Qutriya  hostile to Arab nationalism had preceded them, dating back to 1918, particularly the regimes of the House of Saud and the Hashemites. Their recognition subsequently took a secret form, but its substance never changed.

Thus, a paradox emerged:

  • International and Arab communists recognized a capitalist, settler-colonial project based on the uprooting and dispossession of other people’s homeland, in absolute contradiction with the revolutionary principles of Marxism!
  • Arab rulers recognized the same settlement project on Arab land, in absolute contradiction with Arab nationalism!

In other words, the farthest reaches of the Arab left and the farthest reaches of the Arab right converged early on in the service of Zionism!

On the basis of Arab nationalism, and since 1948, in affiliation—even if from behind the wall—with the rising tide of Arab national unity, the Palestinian masses living inside” Israel” refused to participate in elections to the parliament, the Knesset. The exceptions were Palestinians affiliated with the Israeli Communist Party and some traditional local notables. Consequently, the masses referred to those participating in the elections as traitors, such as Salim Khalil and Jabr Dahash Maadi, among others.

The nationalist forces in the territories occupied in 1948 remained opposed to recognizing “Israel” and participating in its elections. They established the Al-Ard Organization, followed by the Popular Front in the mid-1950s. Among its late prominent figures were Saleh Baransi, Mansour Kardoush, and Ahmad Hussein.

Naturally, this organization was suppressed with extreme violence. It was subsequently followed by the Abnaa al-Balad movement (Sons of the Land), which continued to reject participation in elections. Its leaders were frequently subjected to arrest and trial.

The same position was maintained by the northern branch of the Islamic Movement, led by Sheikh Raed Salah, who, as it is said, did not call upon his supporters to participate in elections, although he did not prohibit them from doing so. However, it is important to recall that Sheikh Raed Salah sent militant volunteers to Syria to fight against the Baathist regime there!

The increasing proportion and number of Arab citizens participating in elections coincided with the growing tide of official Arab normalization and cultural normalization, particularly Palestinian normalization following the Oslo Accords.

These developments made the Palestinians of 1948 feel that they had been left standing on the platform, waiting for a train that would never accommodate them. They had previously regarded the PLO as their sole legitimate representative. However, the Oslo Accords effectively stipulated that the organization represented only Palestinians residing in the West Bank and Gaza Strip at the time these agreements were concluded.

This opened the appetite of certain groups among the Palestinians in the territories occupied in 1948, who had already been inclined toward participating in the “Israel’s elections, to exploit this abandonment. They claimed that these Palestinians had been left without an umbrella of protection! As though the absence of such an umbrella absolves them of their responsibility to remain steadfast!

Consequently, those participating in voting and even running for membership in the Knesset were no longer limited to the Communist Party. Drawing upon the Oslo Accords, Azmi Bishara established a new parliamentary party, the National Democratic Assembly. This entangled some members of the Abnaa al-Balad movement in voting in the elections, albeit on a one-time basis.

Indeed, Azmi Bishara himself ran for prime minister, a step that constituted enormous publicity for what is called ”Israeli” democracy.

The late Edward Said subsequently came to Nazareth to deliver a speech in support of Azmi Bishara. He did not miss the opportunity to attack the late Sadiq Jalal al-Azm, who had criticized Said’s ingratiation with the American administration. Yet al-Azm himself eventually became entangled in taking a position against Arab nationalist Syria!

The popular nationalist and leftist current among Palestinians in the territories occupied in 1948 was shocked by Arab and Palestinian normalization. This gradually increased its weakness, given the expansion of official and cultural Arab normalization on the one hand, and the weakening, retreat, and even withdrawal of the Arab unity current on the other.

Regardless of any debate surrounding these developments, they confirm the influence of the Arab Homeland on the occupied territories.

The discourse rejecting recognition of the “Israel” and rejecting participation in parliamentary candidacy and voting has progressively weakened among the Arab population. Its voice is no longer heard as it once was. Participation has come to appear natural, and even as a revolutionary position, while abstention is portrayed as abandoning the masses.

Some participants in the elections have even taken pride in upholding the slogan of a single state, in contrast to those advocating the two-state solution. Yet the various lists representing the Jewish side have made clear that they oppose even the mere existence of Arabs throughout Palestine. In other words, they support a state for all its settlers.

The exceptions are limited to those who accept the existence of Palestinians without rights, or under Jewish control, and similar arrangements.

The frustration of the Arab masses was further intensified by the initiative of King Abdullah in Saudi Arabia, which was accepted by the various Arab regimes, with the exception of partial reservations expressed by Syria under President Assad and Lebanon under President Lahoud.

Arab intellectuals, for their part, also played a role in marketing normalization and subsequently besieging those who rejected normalization within “Israel”.

The situation was made even worse by Damascus and Hizbullah welcoming Azmi Bishara, despite his being a member of the Knesset. This placed the credibility of all parties under the test of their genuine political and national affiliation.

Bishara headed an attempt in 2010 to circumvent the PLO. This initiative included numerous Palestinians regarded as having nationalist orientations, even though Bishara openly declared that he was, first and foremost, in favor of recognizing “Israel” without ambiguity!

Whenever he abstained from participation, they would implore him to return. He also received $400,000 from Colonel Muammar Gaddafi. However, the initiative eventually collapsed.

Thus, the movement rejecting recognition of “Israel” began to narrow, while an individual’s entry into the Knesset came to be regarded as a militant achievement, enthusiastically celebrated by the machinery of official Arab media and, naturally, by sixth-column intellectuals.

This was particularly striking because these individuals were welcomed in Damascus and the southern suburb of Beirut as though they were genuine Arab nationalists! The occupation authorities recognized this opportunity and moved to encourage it.

Accordingly, Netanyahu and others like him, including Eisenkot, exploited the opportunity to classify the Palestinians of 1948 as enemies of the state and to prohibit any cooperation with them in forming a government. In other words: We do not want you, nor do we want your normalization!

In this way, the Palestinians squandered their position without gaining security.

Nevertheless, their leaders, analysts, and Arab intellectuals celebrate the fact that Palestinians of 1948 obtained 19 Knesset seats, presenting it as a historic victory.

In reality, this is like celebrating and dancing among those who have placed a victim on a pile of firewood and set it ablaze, simply so that they would not have to hear the victim’s screams.

The position ultimately adopted by Palestinians in the territories occupied in 1948 is therefore connected to the general collapse of the Arab situation.

This raises several questions:

  • Did these Palestinians compromise their national and Arab principles voluntarily, or were they driven into doing so?
  • Is participation truly the appropriate path for defending their existence and right of return, and even for defending the historic humanitarian position against the capitalist, settler-colonial usurpation of their homeland?
  • Is the problem really confined to Netanyahu as an individual, rather than to what “Israel” is accomplishing on the ground?
  • Is self-defense to be pursued in the corridors of the Knesset, or in the everyday life of the people, through the consolidation of their existence?

There is no justification for this entanglement, which has been presented as a victory. Nevertheless, the compromise and failure were shared by external and internal actors alike, beginning with the Arab normalizers and extending to the Palestinians in the territories occupied in 1948.

Neither side has any excuse.

Indeed, this compromise has further diminished the standing of Arabs in the eyes of the world’s free people. Moreover, normalization itself constitutes an act of aggression against our people’s right to their homeland.

Perhaps what must be emphasized from an Arab nationalist perspective is that the territorial nation-state Qutriya cannot liberate either the land occupied within its own borders or the land occupied within any other Arab country.

Will this once again turn the debate over the Arab position upside down, allowing it to stand on its feet again?

The Knesset is neither a solution nor a place where rights can be secured. The solution lies in the state of Arab unity: a single Arab nationalist state that grants everyone living within its borders their rights, both to life and to livelihood.

Written 29 October 2026.

____________

The opinions and views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect the opinion of Kana’an’s Editorial Board.